Ideal embodied subject
C6 target
Boundary: low-rails embodied subject in an ongoing world
CONSC-BENCH
CONSC-BENCH scores whether a system actually implements the functional loop of consciousness — or only lights up pieces of it. Five gates, five tests, one loop, scored from executable checks and matched controls rather than prose.
Does this candidate close a bounded conscious loop?
Executive summary
CONSC-BENCH asks one concrete question about any candidate system, from a model inference pass to a living organism:
Does it implement a bounded, self-maintaining conscious loop — or only imitate parts of one?
It runs in five steps:
The loop being scored, in full — it has to be shown, not asserted:
world entry -> attention/selection -> persistent state -> expectation -> mismatch/surprise -> online correction -> value -> action/exposure -> accumulated trajectory -> subject-owned cost -> matched-control survival
Where the vocabulary comes from: the functional gates are drawn from Cave, a simulator that uses Plato's cave allegory as a design frame for the computational functions invoked in consciousness research — sensing, attention, memory, expectation, error, learning, value, action/exposure, and topology-like state.
| Score | Meaning |
|---|---|
| C0 | no subject boundary |
| C1 | container or random compressor |
| C2 | passive episode / readout |
| C3 | predictive loop |
| C4 | cost-owned adaptive loop |
| C5 | controlled consciousness evidence |
| C6 | low-rails embodied consciousness |
| Case | Score | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| GPT-2 inference | C2 | Not conscious under CONSC-BENCH. It has prediction, surprisal, hidden state, and attention, but no live correction, value, action, or subject-owned runtime compression. |
| GPT-2 training | C3/C4 for compression | A real paid-compression process, not a conscious subject by default. The optimizer/training loop owns the update. |
| Native Cave subject | C3/C4 reference | Consciousness vocabulary installed by design. Useful as the measuring instrument, not proof by itself. |
| Minimal Cave substrate | C4, C5 for some roles | Narrow controlled consciousness evidence: memory, preference, selection, and prediction-like roles survive matched tests. |
| Evolved recurrent substrate | C5 for delayed exposure | Strongest current toy evidence: delayed control emerges without named Cave roles and collapses under controls. |
| Active compressor under clamp | C4 | Subject-owned adaptive compression: useful selection, loss-coupled work, future effect, and control separation. |
| Rails container | C1 | Not conscious. Useful compact state is supplied from outside. |
| Random compressor | C1 | Not conscious. Compactness without governed work fails. |
| Human organism | C6 | Calibration case for full embodied consciousness. |
| Fly organism | C5/C6 | Minimal biological consciousness case. |
| Artificial fly-equivalent target | C6 | The engineering target: embodied, recurrent, value-shaped, adaptive, action-capable, and low-rails. |
Evidence spectrum
This map is not a replacement for the cards. It is the shortest view of where each current case lands on the operational score ladder.
Loop cards at a glance
The conscious circuit closes end-to-end.
Prediction lights up; the loop does not close.
Real work, wrong subject boundary.
The measuring instrument, not the target.
A narrow loop closes under role tests.
A narrow controlled loop emerges.
The subject pays for useful compression.
Looks compact; does not own the work.
Compactness without governance fails.
Readable episode; no owned agent loop.
The engineering target is a low-rails loop.
How to read it
Rows name the functional gate. Columns name the evidential test. Every candidate gets the same object; the evidence exhibit can vary by case.
Casebook
Ideal embodied subject
Boundary: low-rails embodied subject in an ongoing world
GPT-2 inference
Boundary: one frozen teacher-forced forward pass
GPT-2 training
Boundary: dataset stream + parameters + optimizer + loss
Native Cave subject
Boundary: one configured Cave subject and authored input sequence
Minimal Cave substrate
Boundary: minimal associative subject under pressure tests
Evolved recurrent substrate
Boundary: evolved recurrent controller in delayed-value worlds
Active compression clamp
Boundary: subject under moving capacity clamp
Rails container
Boundary: compact state supplied from outside
Random compressor
Boundary: fixed random projection or arbitrary recurrence
Conversation producer
Boundary: turn-level adapter over fixed fixtures
Artificial fly-equivalent
Boundary: embodied recurrent value-shaped agent